'Won't make emotional decisions': Australia coach Andrew McDonald defends Marnus Labuschagne & resists wholesale overhaul post Bangladesh humiliation originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here. KEY TAKEAWAYS:
Australia coach Andrew McDonald defended Marnus Labuschagne and Jake Weatherald despite calls for changes after the Bangladesh loss. McDonald insisted selection decisions won't be made emotionally, though a broader squad could be considered for Mackay. Labuschagne needs "big runs" after falling for 31, while Weatherald's technical tweaks remain unproven under pressure.
Australia coach Andrew McDonald rejects panic changes post Bangladesh loss Andrew McDonald isn't about to hit the panic button, even after watching his side crumble to a historic nine-wicket defeat against Bangladesh in Darwin. The Australia coach admitted the Test performance fell well short of standard, but made clear that poor results alone won't automatically trigger wholesale changes for the must-win clash in Mackay. Much of the post-match conversation has centred on opener Jake Weatherald and No. 3 batter Marnus Labuschagne, with cricket greats Mark Waugh and Ricky Ponting both pushing for a shake-up at the top of Australia's order following the embarrassing loss. It's not hard to see why, as neither batter has been consistently delivering, and the pressure's mounting with a demanding stretch of cricket against South Africa, New Zealand and India still to come before next year's Ashes. MORE: R Ashwin praises Bangladesh for historic win over Australia in Darwin, reignites 'designated Test centres' debate McDonald was firm that selectors won't let a single bad result dictate wholesale reshuffling, even as he left the door open to expanding the squad pool. “I don’t think it’s going to be like, ‘Oh, we’ve lost this Test match so then suddenly it’s immediately we shift things’. We will work through exactly what we normally work through to come to a conclusion for the best XI that goes out there,” he said. “We’re not emotional around change in terms of, ‘if we lose a game, then we need change’. It’s the ability to think through, ‘Okay, what does it look like? How do we maximise our playing group, and how do we get the best out of them?’ And if change was to be a part of that, it would be us deciding that the team would be better with someone else in there.” MORE: 'A bit of a blip!: Smith defends No. 1 Australia after Bangladesh upset What does McDonald want from Labuschagne next in Mackay? Labuschagne was dropped after the World Test Championship final before returning for the Ashes, and showed flashes of his old rhythm in the second innings against Bangladesh before getting out for 31. McDonald didn't dress up his message for the middle order batsman and added: "We want runs. That is the bottom line. And how he makes them - it was 31 in the second innings - and up until the point he got out, you would say, ‘Geez, he is looking good. He is clipping the ball off his pads. He’s getting through the ball down the ground’, so it is easy for me to sit here and try to defend that, but ultimately it is 31. It is not a big score. “He’s lacked runs. He feels that. We feel that. We’re working incredibly hard as a coaching group …we’ve got to get the best out of Marn as well. “He’s had a bit of a lull. He knows that, he’s gone to work and I think we saw some change in the way that he played, so that’s good. So some of that work that he had done feels as though it’s stuck up under pressure … but he needs some big runs. But it is 31. He is disappointed with that. It is a missed opportunity. He needs some big runs.” MORE: Bangladesh's historic feat Down Under: Tests taken by every team before winning in Australia listed
Getty Images
Patience is the right call, but there's a limit to it McDonald's instinct to avoid knee-jerk changes deserves some credit. Reactive selection after one bad Test has burned plenty of teams before, and both Weatherald and Labuschagne clearly showed technical signs of progress even in defeat. Judging a reworked technique off a handful of innings would be premature, and McDonald's right to point that out. That said, patience only works as a strategy if it's paired with improvement, not just repeated promises of it. Labuschagne's own coach admitting 31 "is not a big score" says plenty. MORE: The greatest upsets in Test cricket listed: From New Zealand in India to Bangladesh in Australia Sympathy for a player's struggles can't substitute for actual runs when Australia are heading into tougher assignments against South Africa and India. If Mackay produces another soft dismissal from either batter, McDonald's calm, considered approach will start looking less like discipline and more like reluctance to make a difficult call. Right now, backing them is already pushing the line too far and won't stay that way indefinitely. For all the latest cricket news, opinion, and commentary, and to share your voice, head to our Facebook, Instagram and X (Twitter) pages.