Twelve months ago, managers were debating where Brian Thomas Jr. ranked among the position league-wide. Now the debate is about where he ranks in his own receiver room, and that gap between the hype and the price is exactly why he’s worth buying.
I’m not projecting a repeat of the rookie explosion. I do think Thomas is still the WR1 in this offense, and the discount attached to his name after last season makes him one of the better value plays at the position.
Should You Draft Brian Thomas Jr. in Fantasy Football?
Thomas’ Redraft Fantasy Football Value
The box score from last season is rough to look at. Thomas managed a single top-12 week and three top-24 finishes, two fewer top-24 weeks than Parker Washington, a teammate who was barely on the fantasy radar a year earlier.
That’s brutal. That’s brutal for any player, nevermind one who had a real claim to be considered one of the most promissing in the sport after a dynamic rookie campaign.
The red zone usage is what really stood out in trying to explain the dismal performance.
Thomas’ red zone target rate fell from 28.6% as a rookie to 9.4% last season, a collapse that took away the easiest scoring chances an offense can hand a receiver. Layer in that 46.2% of his targets last season traveled 15 or more yards downfield, up from 31.6% as a rookie, and the profile looks a lot like Gabe Davis of years past.
He was pigeon holed into needing explosive plays instead of paying the bills closer to the goal line, a role shift that introduces a floor that didn’t seem fathomable after 2024.
Even accounting for that swing, I’m buying the talent and the direction of this offense. Thomas’ rookie tape was more encouraging than his second season was discouraging, and Jacksonville’s passing game gives him a real path back. The discount is driving my stance. Drafting a player with this kind of downside gets a lot easier when he’s not costing you a premium pick: load up on stable profiles early and roll the dice on BTJ.
Thomas’ Dynasty Fantasy Football Value
This is a decision point for Thomas managers. One more season likely tells you which direction his career is heading. A strong bounce-back sends his price climbing fast, and a repeat of last season probably drops him out of the tier of receivers you can trust as a weekly starter.
I’m buying now, and it’s a process bet more than a results one. The risk is real, but talent on the rise at this price doesn’t come around often, especially when attached to an above average offense.
The same logic from redraft applies here. Build your roster around dependable pieces first, then use spots like this one on a talented player you’re willing to trust.
Looking to hone your drafting skills? Our FREE Fantasy Football Mock Draft Simulator gets you through an entire draft, in any format, as you look to hone your skills for draft day!
This article originally appeared on Pro Football Network.