India's 3-or-4 spinner dilemma ahead of 1st Test against Sri Lanka at Galle originally appeared on Cricket News. Add Cricket News as a Preferred Source by clicking here. KEY TAKEAWAYS:
India must pick between three or four spinners for the opening Galle Test vs Sri Lanka, with Saransh Jain fighting for a place. Bowling coach Morkel backed the variety among three left-arm spinners despite them sharing the same style. Team balance, batting depth, and the choice of second seamer alongside Siraj all hang on this call.
Should India play Saransh Jain as an additional spinner against Sri Lanka in Galle? Spin has always decided matches at Galle, and this time round it might just decide India's entire team combination. Four slow bowlers made the trip. Ravindra Jadeja, Kuldeep Yadav, Manav Suthar and uncapped off-spinner Saransh Jain, who stepped in after Washington Sundar picked up an injury, but only three, at most, are likely to get a game. That leaves the team management with a genuinely tricky call to make, one that says a lot about how India wants to approach the opening Test of this series. Jadeja and Kuldeep pick themselves. One offers control and the bat-and-ball utility that's kept him in the side for over a decade; the other brings wrist-spin wizardry and wickets in bunches, even if his overs get carefully rationed to keep him fresh. MORE: ICYMI: What India’s warm-up win over Sri Lanka tells us before the upcoming Tests
(getty)
That's exactly what happened in the practice game at the NCC, where Kuldeep sent down 18 overs in the first innings and was rested entirely in the second, as part of his workload management. The interesting bit is Suthar. He was excellent on debut against Afghanistan last month, snapping up seven wickets, and it would be a surprise, and probably the wrong call, to leave him out now. Bowling coach Morne Morkel isn't fussed that three of India's spin options all operate left-arm. "Kuldeep is there, and he's the attacking sort of bowler and for us, his experience and class can't look past. So yeah, I think for us they're all different in their way," Morkel said. "So one (Suthar) turns a bit more, one (Jadeja) is slightly more accurate, and I don't think it's a (three left-arm spinners) massive concern for us. "It's just how Gill is going to use those guys at certain times. But yeah, I mean in terms of skill, they've got the skill to get the 20 wickets for us." But that leaves Jain in a spot of bother. He toiled away in the practice match but didn't have the control or the cutting edge to force his way into serious contention. Earlier this year on the India A tour of Sri Lanka, he'd made a real case for himself as he belted out an unbeaten 70 alongside six wickets in the second game. But recent form counts for more than a good few weeks ago, and Suthar's Test debut simply outweighs it. Although Jain's batting is a nice bonus, it is not a guarantee of selection. MORE: Gambhir's fate as India Test head coach based on IND vs SL Test series result revealed Why should India go with three spinners instead of four? Go with three spinners instead of four, and suddenly there's room for an extra batter, which matters a great deal at a ground where the pitch is expected to break down as the match wears on. Morkel himself flagged this, having inspected the surface two days out: "Traditionally, also if you look at the venue, how it stacks and how it's been played up, that's sort of the way (three spinners) to go I think. The way we go with our spin bowling attack or spinners, it's a very attacking option. "The first two days will belong to the batting side. Whatever happens at the toss, if you bat first make sure you go big and if you bowl first get the ball in the right areas." MORE: Vaas names Indian player to look out for vs Sri Lanka in upcoming Test series
(getty)
History backs him up as spinners at Galle have taken 1,032 wickets at 31.01, compared to 477 at 36.18 for pace. If India end up batting last on a crumbling fourth-innings pitch, that extra batting slot could be the difference between saving a Test and losing one. There's also the second seamer question alongside Mohammed Siraj, a straight fight between Gurnoor Brar and Prasidh Krishna, neither of whom offers much with the bat, which only strengthens the case for extra batting depth elsewhere in the XI. Playing it safe is the smart move here for India Picking three spinners over four is the right call, and it isn't close. Jain's Test claims rest on one good knock and a six-wicket haul from an A-tour game: solid, but nowhere near enough to leapfrog a bowler who took seven wickets on Test debut a month ago. MORE: IND vs SL 1st Test predicted playing XIs: India's selection dilemma Suthar has earned his spot the hard way, and dropping him now would send a confusing message about how India rewards form. More importantly, this decision isn't really about spin at all; it's about survival on a pitch that gets uglier by the day. An extra batter gives India a proper buffer for the fourth innings, when Galle traditionally turns into a minefield. Morkel's comments make it fairly obvious which way the team's thinking is headed, and for once, the conservative option looks like the smart one too. For all the latest cricket news, opinion and commentary and to share your voice head to our Facebook, Instagram and X (Twitter) pages.